Beneful Healthy Puppy With Farm-Raised Chicken vs Purina ONE True Instinct With Real Chicken and Duck High Protein Puppy Food Formula Natural With Added Vitamins, Minerals and Nutrients

Order follows the Universal Score — the same deterministic engine, the same rules, for every product. Brands can't pay for placement.

The scores

Purina ONE True Instinct With Real Chicken and Duck High Protein Puppy Food Formula Natural With Added Vitamins, Minerals and Nutrients

82

Good · Confidence A

Beneful Healthy Puppy With Farm-Raised Chicken

81

Good · Confidence A

Bowlmark scores are independent opinions based on published label information and cited references. They are educational, not veterinary advice, and no substitute for your vet — especially for medical conditions or prescription diets.

Pillar by pillar

Weighted pillar contributions from each product's stored score — nutritional adequacy, ingredient quality, additives & processing, transparency.

MetricPurina ONEBeneful
Nutritional adequacy3535
Ingredient quality2123
Additives & processing1717
Transparency96

Guaranteed analysis

As printed on each label; dry-matter protein removes the moisture so wet and dry read on the same basis.

MetricPurina ONEBeneful
Protein32%28%
Fat17%14%
Fiber3%4%
Moisture12%12%
Protein (dry-matter)36.4%31.8%

First five ingredients

Purina ONE

  1. Chicken
  2. chicken meal
  3. soybean meal
  4. whole grain wheat
  5. beef fat preserved with mixed-tocopherols

Beneful

  1. Chicken
  2. whole grain corn
  3. chicken by-product meal
  4. soybean meal
  5. corn protein meal

Flags on the label

Purina ONE

  • corn appears as 3 fractions in the top 8
  • Synthetic vitamin K3 — questioned safety margin vs natural K sources

Beneful

  • Synthetic vitamin K3 — questioned safety margin vs natural K sources

Cite this page

Bowlmark. "Purina ONE True Instinct With Real Chicken and Duck High Protein Puppy Food Formula Natural With Added Vitamins, Minerals and Nutrients vs Beneful Healthy Puppy With Farm-Raised Chicken." https://www.bowlmark.com/compare/beneful-healthy-puppy-with-farm-raised-chicken-vs-purina-one-true-instinct-with-real-chicken-and-duck-high-protein-puppy-food-formula-natural-with-added-vitamins-minerals-and-nutrients

Engine
Methodology engine v1.1.0 · config 13c99e2f
Verified
Last verified September 5, 2026

The engine and config above are the ones stamped on this page's score — the exact pair that produced the number shown.

How the engine worksCitation registry